Macmillan the committee is comprised of wellknown mountaineers. In 1965, 54% of the usage panel disapproved of the phrase is comprised of. Grammar rules the blue book of grammar and punctuation. Why the first comprise is used while in the second is comprised of. On the other hand, most grammar sources i checked 2, 3, 4 agree that is comprised of is an incorrect phrase. The one you can say is is composed of, so you could say, our nation is composed of many ethnic groups.
She cites many of the usual suspects in schoolmarmstyle prescriptive rules of this sort. Written with the wit, warmth, and accessibility that the podcasts are known for, grammar girl s quick and dirty tips for better writing covers the grammar rules and wordchoice guidelines that can confound even the best writers. Comprise its good to be able to vary your vocabulary sometimes, especially if you need to repeat an idea. The book was composed of three chapters and a glossary. Written with the wit, warmth, and accessibility that the podcasts are known for, grammar girls quick and dirty tips for better writing covers the grammar rules and word. On the other hand, is composed of is perfectly acceptable. In the absence of a clear context regarding how known or unknown is the number of books available for me to read, should i use what book to read or which book to read i dont know what book to read i dont know how many books there are for me to choose from. A way with words is a fun and funny radio show and podcast about language. Irony is the use of words to express something different from and often opposite to their literal. You may be interested in my book, business writing with heart. The course is comprised of ten lectures and five seminars on the theory of economics and banking. Jul 18, 2008 i dont know when or how it started, but comprise and composed of have somehow become intertwined, resulting in the use of comprised of.
Get your copy of the blue book of grammar and punctuation. By english grammar today a reference to written and spoken english grammar and usage cambridge dictionary. Comprised of is an expression in english that means to compose or constitute. Compose means to be or constitute a part of element of or to make up or form the basis of, as in eight slices compose the pie. Comprised of has been in use for centuries, but usage guides in the early 20th. The students forgot to bring their books means that an.
Some even avoid using them to avoid commiting mistakes. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. In this highly acclaimed revision, grammatical descriptions and teaching suggestions are organized into sections dealing with form, meaning, and use. Comprise means include, as in haydns piano sonata no. Dec 20, 2016 the words comprise and compose are two of the most commonly misused terms in the english language. At the beginning of this show, we said that comprise means contain, but in her book woe is i the respected grammar writer patricia oconnor. The writing resource bitesized lessons to improve your. Definition of comprised of in the idioms dictionary. The first step in understanding the differences is to understand their definitions.
Basically, these two words are the opposite of one another. The grammar book, second edition helps teachers and future teachers grasp the linguistic system and details of english grammar, providing more information on how structures are used at the discourse level. The brothers fowler made note of the construction comprised of in their book. She cites many of the usual suspects in schoolmarmstyle. Comprise, but not compose, can be used with the parts that make up something as the subject. Grammar girls quick and dirty tips for better writing. The words comprise and compose are two of the most commonly misused terms in the english language. While its use is common in writing and speech, it has been attacked by some language professionals as incorrect.
Grammarly can save you from misspellings, grammatical and punctuation mistakes. Data management comprises many more specialized areas of study. In terms of our educationbased sentence, the correct version is 16 boys and 12 girls compose the class. The grammar in use book series by multiple authors includes books advanced grammar in use supplementary exercises with answers, english grammar in use book without answers. In 1965, 54% of the usage panel disapproved of the phrase is comprised of, whereas in 2005, 65% approved, which means that only 35% disapproved.
As things stand, without context or further modifications, books creates a generic sentence that works better than its counterpart. Millions of people around the world communicate better thanks to mignon fogarty, aka grammar girl, whose toprated weekly grammar podcast has been downloaded more than 30 million times. Grammar girls quick and dirty tips for better writing by. I dont know when or how it started, but comprise and composed of have somehow become intertwined, resulting in the use of comprised of. A test at lunch today i read the following sentence in an advertising supplement in the new york times. While his quest is harmless, it shows that zealots can dominate the web.
What sets it apart from other grammar books is its unique pedagogical focus. This book, like all of grammar girls prior books and podcasts, is well written with. After realizing her fans were asking the same questions over and over, mignon decided to focus her attention on those words that continuously confound the masses. Garners modern american usage, brysons dictionary for writers and editors, and walraffs word court. Grammar is seen to be a resource for making meaning in textually and socially appropriate ways. Grammar underground podcast grammar underground with. Mar 04, 2014 grammar girl explains the difference between who vs. Meanwhile, the term compose is a verb meaning to constitute or make up a whole. Composed of and comprised of would appear to mean the exact same thing for people who misunderstand the word comprise. The zero tolerance approach to punctuation by lynne truss, the elements of style by william strunk jr. Mignon fogarty born 1967 is a former faculty member in journalism at the university of nevada, reno, and a former science writer who produces an educational podcast about english.
Grammar girl herself offered me an advance copy for. Mar 26, 2007 composed of and comprised of would appear to mean the exact same thing for people who misunderstand the word comprise. As grammar studies become more advanced and specialized at the university level, the textbooks also become narrower in focus, because they present higher. Grammar girl explains the difference between who vs.
As a freelance editor, i have to be an expert on at least one style guide, have a working knowledge of several more style guides, and be cognizant of even more style guides. We can also use it in the passive voice in the form be comprised of. To the delight of word nerds everywhere, grammar girls quick and dirty tips for better writing came out yesterday. So still, for now, composed of is correct and comprised of is incorrect. Compose and comprise, copy editing, grammar the difference between compose and comprise isnt important to everyone. By identifying your clauses as defining or nondefining, you can easily remember when to use which and when to use that. Its common for speakers to say that a basketball team is comprised of five players instead of is composed of five players. For example, you might say, a full pack comprises 52 cards. For grammar girl, bonnie trenga explains how to use comprise properly.
The correct version put forward by grammar guides is to used composed of or comprises such as the cake is composed of flour and eggs or comprises flour and eggs. Vehicle tire comprising a tread composed of a plurality of compounds and a layer of. The blue book of grammar and punctuation, tenth edition designed to answer the most pressing grammar, punctuation, capitalization, and usage questions. Just as you cant say, the house includes of seven rooms, you can. In sentences i edit, it often takes careful thought to decide just which one of these things the article should say. You can use the phrase is composed of, but you cannot use the phrase is comprised of. For example, the term english grammar may refer to the whole of english grammar. Parts compose the whole, and the whole comprises the parts. It looks to me like most people lean toward american grammar, and i have to admit im a little biased toward it myselfi have. Sep 18, 2009 one of these is allowed, and one is not. For example, we could say that the united states comprises 50 states and that the 50 states compose the united states. The term grammar can also describe the rules which govern the linguistic behavior of a group of speakers. This is the same format that grammar textbooks suited for older or more advanced students often have, except that the more advanced textbooks would be comprised. U sually in this space, i aim to educate you on grammar, punctuation, style, and other language topics.
Well, unfortunately, comprised of is a faulty construction. When you use comprise, youre talking about all the parts that make up something. This is the same format that grammar textbooks suited for older or more advanced students often have, except that the more advanced textbooks would be comprised of more difficult exercises. English grammar today a reference to written and spoken english grammar and usage cambridge dictionary. R ecently on the copyediting blog, i wrote about how editors could measure their productivity. Lets take a closer look at the definitions to put this in context. The american heritage guide to contemporary usage and style however, has noticed an interesting trend. Cohosts martha barnette and grant barrett talk with callers from around the world about. Grammar girls 101 misused words youll never confuse again by. If you are ready to learn more, study up on defining and nondefining clauses.
Feb 05, 2015 composed of, consists of, and comprises are subtly different. For example, a basketball team comprises five players. But, increasingly, the usage panels of major dictionaries are accepting the use of comprise for compose, especially in the passive voice. A seasonal selection of new and not so new books about language that are anything but dull. Older renters comprise largest share of market forbes.
Is the phrase comprised of correct, or should composed of replace. Jul 08, 2008 written with the wit, warmth, and accessibility that the podcasts are known for, grammar girl s quick and dirty tips for better writing covers the grammar rules and wordchoice guidelines that can confound even the best writers. Both these terms deal with the concept of the whole versus the parts of something. Im guessing people who argue that comprised of and composed of have some subtle difference in meaning to them, or that limiting the definition of comprise is somehow archaic and myopic. Mignon fogarty born 1967 is a former faculty member in journalism at the university of nevada, reno, and a former science writer who produces an educational podcast about english grammar and usage titled grammar girl s quick and dirty tips for better writing, which was named one of the best podcasts of 2007 by itunes. The soviet union comprised several socialist republics.
Our wine team is comprised of devoted wine lovers who are some of the most respected professionals in the industry. Grammar girls 101 misused words youll never confuse again book. In other words, this house has or contains seven rooms. Pelleligible students comprise 21 percent of princetons freshman class princeton university young adults comprise largest group of suspended voters the collegian boom. But remember this is quite formal, and is probably best kept for.
Cohosts martha barnette and grant barrett talk with callers from around the world about linguistics, slang, new words, jokes, riddles, word games, grammar, old sayings, word origins, regional dialects, family expressions, bo. Comprised of errors everything language and grammar. Many grammar guides actually suggest that is comprised of is. Which and that are common words, but they are important. The important thing to remember when youre using the word comprise is that the item that is the whole shebang comes first in the sentence. The course is comprised of two essays plus three assignments. While his quest is harmless, it shows that zealots. Wikipedia editor bryan henderson has made it his crusade to edit out the phrase comprised of in more than 5 million articles.
Composed of, consists of, and comprises are subtly different. In the absence of a clear context regarding how known or unknown is the number of books available for me to read, should i use what book to read or which book to read i dont know. The pack is the whole shebang, so it comes first in the sentence. Mignon fogarty, the creator of grammar girl and the founder of the quick and dirty tips network, is also the author of the new york times bestselling grammar girls quick and dirty. All the grammar, punctuation, and usage rules and examples on the website plus dozens of quizzes with answers. Longman the class is comprised mainly of italian and french students. The cambridge advanced learners dictionary, collins english dictionary and the oxford dictionaries regard the form comprised of as standard english.
487 1063 640 1553 1115 181 1075 863 431 359 91 853 917 463 1316 786 653 1275 1292 155 621 1429 921 101 29 263 928 705 622 1399 787 207 853